So, sorry, but how are you not his girlfriend? You hang out, you do sexual and affectionate things with him, you've been introduced to his support system who all acknowledge you as his gf, he has your face as his screen saver. Pretty sure from everything you've said, that you are his girlfriend. The only thing that seems to be missing is that he's not specifically asked you to be, but frankly, plenty of relationships don't have that step, because everyone just accepts it as fact. Like in your situation.
If you don't want to be his girlfriend, you should probably explicitly explain this.
I think u are being dramatic.
Ur mom wanted her daughter to have both rings.
When did it become mandatory to give potential in laws heirlooms?
Marriages are not 100% and maybe ur mom didn’t want to take the chance.
Let’s say ur dad gave u both his fathers watches, would u be okay with ur sister being upset one wasn’t given to her for her current bf?
Well someone needs to explain irony to Danielle.
Get rid of her.
So, sorry, but how are you not his girlfriend? You hang out, you do sexual and affectionate things with him, you've been introduced to his support system who all acknowledge you as his gf, he has your face as his screen saver. Pretty sure from everything you've said, that you are his girlfriend. The only thing that seems to be missing is that he's not specifically asked you to be, but frankly, plenty of relationships don't have that step, because everyone just accepts it as fact. Like in your situation.
If you don't want to be his girlfriend, you should probably explicitly explain this.
Clearly you both need to work on communication.